Think market income below Rs 12 lakh is tax free? TaxBuddy founder warns how this common mistake could attract big tax notice

A growing number of retail investors in India are discovering that earning less than ₹12 lakh from stock markets does not automatically mean a tax exemption. According to Sujit Bangar, founder of TaxBuddy.com, investors often get caught off guard because they overlook how each type of income is taxed under different rules.

In a recent example, Bangar highlighted the case of a full-time investor who earned 7 lakh from the market. Expecting zero tax, the investor instead received a tax notice demanding 74,375.

Breakdown of the investor's income

The investor’s earnings included:

  • 3 lakh in intraday losses
  • ₹2.5 lakh from futures and options (F&O) gains
  • ₹3.5 lakh in short-term capital gains (STCG)
  • ₹4 lakh in long-term capital gains (LTCG)
  • The total profit was under ₹12 lakh. However, that did not make it exempt from tax.

How tax rules treat different incomes
Tax laws treat each income type separately:

Intraday trading: Treated as speculative business income, taxed at slab rates, and losses can only be adjusted against speculative profits. Losses can be carried forward for four years.

Futures and Options (F&O): Classified as non-speculative business income, taxed at slab rates. Losses have broader set-off options and an eight-year carry-forward period.

Short-term capital gains (STCG): Taxed at a flat rate of 20% under Section 111A. STCG losses can offset both STCG and LTCG.

Long-term capital gains (LTCG): Only ₹1.25 lakh is exempt under Section 112A. Any amount above that is taxed at 12.5%. No indexation benefits or Section 87A rebate apply.

Tax confusion is common

Don’t confuse low income with low tax,” Bangar said in a detailed LinkedIn post. “Understand how each income is classified—and taxed.”

He pointed out that the investor’s mistake was not the profit amount but how the gains were treated under tax law. “What got him in trouble wasn’t profit—it was classification.”

Retail investing surge meets tax surprises

Bangar’s post comes at a time when millions of Indians are entering the stock market through trading apps, often without full knowledge of tax laws.

“Tag someone who trades but thinks ₹12L = ‘tax-free zone,’” Bangar wrote. His message underlines the importance of understanding tax rules before investing.

For new and existing investors, the key takeaway is this: knowing how your income is classified matters more than how much you earn.

Source Link: https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/new-updates/think-market-income-below-rs-12-lakh-is-tax-free-taxbuddy-founder-warns-how-this-common-mistake-could-attract-big-tax-notice/articleshow/122201761.cms?from=mdr

Website Link: https://www.taxbuddy.com/

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

ITR Filing 2025: How Salaried Taxpayers Can Maximise Their Refunds

For some salaried taxpayers , the tax return season may feel like a chore, yet it is also one of the few chances to get some money back, especially if too much tax was deducted over the year. With the ITR filing window now open for ITR 1 and ITR 4, this is a crucial time for salaried employees to know how they can maximise their refunds this year. Not always but sometimes there’s a real possibility that you have overpaid taxes, without even realising it. This usually happens when your employer deducts more tax than required or when you forget to account for deductions that never made it into your Form 16. It could be rent receipts you didn’t submit on time, a last-minute ELSS investment, or home loan interest that didn’t get factored in. Whatever the case, filing your return is how you claim that excess tax back. What Triggers a Refund? There are a few common scenarios where salaried people end up paying more tax than necessary: You have changed jobs during the year and both ...
Read more

You can file ITR first, pay income tax later: Here’s how to use this feature on e-filing portal

The income tax department has launched a new feature on the income tax   e-filing  website that allows an individual to pay income tax later. This means that an individual can continue to file ITR without paying the pending income taxes first. Once the ITR is filed, then the income tax amount can be paid, albeit with some conditions. Earlier the ITR could only be filed once the due taxes were paid. “Income tax department has given an option of pay later when we file income tax return (ITR) . Therefore, an individual can file an ITR without paying income tax dues first by using the pay later option,” said CA Abhinit Singh, Founder, Ready Accountant, a Kolkata-based educational institution. Read below to find out how to use the ‘Pay Later’ option on the Income Tax Department’s e-filing portal. Pay later facility is available for this tax payment According to Mihir Tanna, Associate Director (Direct Tax), S K Patodia & Associates, a Mumbai-based CA firm, “The ‘Pay...
Read more

Taxman knows more than you think: Here's why clean ITR filing matters

Some taxpayers underreport income or inflate deductions in order to save money that goes to the government. But experts warn that this is a high-stakes gamble in today’s data-driven tax environment. With the Income Tax Department now armed with sophisticated tools and deep access to financial information, from your bank transactions and property deals to your stock market activity, there’s little room to hide.   Taxman’s eyes everywhere: What the department already knows   “The Income Tax Department gets financial data from multiple channels, banks, mutual funds, employers, registrars, and more,” says Suresh Surana, charter accountant.   This includes: TDS/TCS details from Form 24Q/26Q   High-value transactions under the Statement of Financial Transactions (SFT)   Integrated PAN-linked records from property sales, share investments, and foreign remittances   Salary, rent, capital gains, and GST data through the Annual Information Statement (AIS) and Form 2...
Read more